MFH Gulf Porsche 917K 1/24th vs Fujimi Martini Porsche 917K

[Borez 714]

OK, so for my next build I've decided to build the MFH 917K 1/24th Ver B in the JW Automotive Gulf colours ( yes I'm doing the Gulf Colours! )

 

This is my first MFH kit too so I'm kinda excited and a little nervy as I have no idea what's ahead. Another learning curve I guess.

 

Also haven't decided whether to build the No.19, 71 Sarth 24 hours or the No.1 Monza 1000Km version yet.

 

I'm leaning towards the Monza car at the moment.

 

But anyway, the kit arrived this afternoon. And very nice it is too. Santa came early in my house.

 

 

So basically I now have to start sorting though this lot.

 

 

 

 

Unfortunately, and annoyingly, it's all gone back in the box as the kit is completely missing the PE parts and the bulkhead section. Not a good start really.

 

I've contacted the supplier and I'm waiting for an answer on that.

 

Anyway....

 

To mix it up a bit.

 

I also have the Fujimi 22 Martini 1971 Le Mans winning 917K.

 

 

Which I intend to build in tandem with the MFH kit using the MFH as reference to see what kind of standard I can detail the Fujimi.

 

Whether I can get it anywhere near the MFH kit only time will tell I guess.

 

On order for the Fujimi are PE parts, upgraded brakes and the Historic Racing Miniatures HRM-303 engine and bulkhead transkit. I'll be scratch-building everything else; including the frame.

 

I'm also thinking about moderately weathering both kits for a bit of race authenticity.

 

So there you have it really, bit off way more than I can chew again.

 

 

 

 

What could possibly go wrong?

 

 

Thanks for looking.

 

 

 

 

Edited December 20, 2016 by Borez

[Spookytooth 10,032]

I think that I shall sit in for the ride Borez. 

 

Simon.

[Borez 714]

18 minutes ago, Spookytooth said:

I think that I shall sit in for the ride Borez. 

 

Simon.

 

Thanks Simon.

 

The MFH looks pretty great, I've been reading though the instructions. There's a lot to do on this for sure.

 

Shame I don't have the PE parts though, kinda annoying considering the cost of these things.

[Spookytooth 10,032]

I could not agree more with you Borez.

What ever kit you buy, you would like all the bits there.

It has happened to me , missing decals/instructions, whole sprues.

 

Looking forward to the build anyhow Borez.

 

Simon.

[Schwarz-Brot 486]

Wow, this is going to be interesting. I am especially following what you think about the Fujimi kit in direct comparison to the MFH. Did I say this is going to be interesting?

[Borez 714]

11 minutes ago, Schwarz-Brot said:

Wow, this is going to be interesting. I am especially following what you think about the Fujimi kit in direct comparison to the MFH. Did I say this is going to be interesting?

 

 

Well to be honest on first impressions the MFH is understandably in a different league to the Fujimi kit, there's no engine in the Fujimi kit for starters ( thus the extra transkit ) and there's no rear frame as such, just some cosmetic bare bones. I'm hoping some scratch building will change all of that though.

 

The bodywork will be an interesting comparison though. I'll do an A - B of the two over the next couple of days.

 

I'd also love to take all of the parts out and have a proper look, but they're staying in the box until I can confirm what's happening about the PE parts. I really hope I don't have to send the MFH back, that would be a PITA. Annoying really as I wanted to get on with cleaning everything up over the weekend as I have time off at the moment.

Edited December 20, 2016 by Borez

[injidup 319]

I have the Fujimi kit so will be eagerly watching this build. Hope you get your missing parts soon! Also interested to see how you get on with the engine for the Fujimi.

[Hamden 3,883]

 

 

Another very interesting project(s) I'll pull up seat and follow along if you don't mind?

Hope you get the missing parts soon!

 

   Roger

[Pouln 613]

Great idea to the do both in tandem. If you have this shadow behind you all the time, it is probably me following you.

[rjfk2002 155]

Also try contacting MFH directly for replacement parts. Their customer service is excellent. I had a broken resin part in one of my kits that they replaced free of charge. 

 

Rich

Edited December 21, 2016 by rjfk2002
Typo

[Borez 714]

30 minutes ago, rjfk2002 said:

Also try contacting MFH directly for replacement parts. Their customer service is excellent. I had a broken resin part in one on my kits that they replaced free of charge. 

 

Rich

 

Well considering I'm getting no response from the supplier from multiple emails yet I may just have to do this. I'll be furious if I have to go down that route though. I mean, it's not really a replacement, it's parts that should have been in the box.

 

No naming and shaming quite yet though as it's the silly season. I do however know they're working because they dispatched a separate order to me this morning.

Edited December 21, 2016 by Borez

[Borez 714]

Quick update: The vendor got in touch, I'll have to have the parts sent to me from Japan which is a little annoying.

 

But at least I can get on with sorting and prepping the parts that I do have.

[Spookytooth 10,032]

Annoying as it may seem, at least you are getting answers as well as the missing parts.

 

Simon.

[Borez 714]

OK, so before I start sorting, ordering and cleaning all of the MFH parts I thought I'd do a quick comparison between the MFH and Fujimi body shells.

 

As you can see from the pics ( hopefully ) The Fujimi body is quite a bit wider than the MFH shell.

 

 

 

 

 

The cockpit on the MFH is smaller in comparison and tapers in more. Just an overall narrower, sleeker design. I really didn't think there would be as much difference to be honest. Which one is more historically accurate I have no idea, I presume the MFH. 

 

Looks like I'll be cutting holes in the Fujimi for the fuel filler cap and strengthening the pretty weak looking bodywork hinges.

 

I also intend to separate the drivers door on the fujimi, not sure if I'll be doing the same on the MFH though ( the thought actually scares me )

 

Also this great lump of a book arrived in the post. Managed to pick one up cheap (ish ) on ebay. 

 

 

Some great pics though, especially of the engine. Nice pics of the factory too. What I didn't know is that there was also a 6.6 litre 16 cylinder version of the engine ( I presume for Can-Am.  ) Must have been a beast to drive.

 

I shall be digesting the contents over the Christmas period.

 

Still trying to work out which chassis number the Gulf car actually is if anyone has any ideas?

 

And that's it for now really, sorting time.

 

Thanks for looking.

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Spookytooth 10,032]

A nice bit of reference you got there Borez.

It should answer any queries you have.

 

Simon.

[Borez 714]

5 minutes ago, Spookytooth said:

A nice bit of reference you got there Borez.

It should answer any queries you have.

 

Simon.

 

You say that, I'm still trying to work out the chassis number though.

 

I'm sure I'll get there.

Edited December 22, 2016 by Borez

[sharknose156 1,128]

Borez !! you are the man !! Fantastic ... go for it.   and Merry Christmas 

[MetroRacing 651]

Damn it, late to the party like usual.

Well at least it's not really begun yet 😉

 

That is quite a difference in width. Is it the same for the length? It looks like comparing 1/24 to 1/25 is the reason I ask.

 

Ashley

[injidup 319]

I think the Gulf car may be chassis 917-016, according to the Haynes manual for the 917...

917-016

Perhaps one of the most celebrated 917s, this is the JW Automotive car with which Pedro Rodriquez dominated at Brands Hatch in 1970. He and Leo Kunnen also drove it to win at Monza and Watkins Glen that year. During 1971 it was mainly used for practice. Gerry Sutherfield owned it for many years before selling it to Indianapolis based Chris McAllister in the 1990s

[Borez 714]

44 minutes ago, MetroRacing said:

Damn it, late to the party like usual.

Well at least it's not really begun yet 😉

 

That is quite a difference in width. Is it the same for the length? It looks like comparing 1/24 to 1/25 is the reason I ask.

 

Ashley

 

I thought that,  it actually looks like a different scale to me too. The length is pretty much the same though.

 

 

41 minutes ago, injidup said:

I think the Gulf car may be chassis 917-016, according to the Haynes manual for the 917...

 

 

 

Thanks, I'll look into this a bit more, I also have the Haynes manual.

Edited December 23, 2016 by Borez

[Borez 714]

14 hours ago, injidup said:

I think the Gulf car may be chassis 917-016, according to the Haynes manual for the 917...

 

 

 

 

I found out the info on these cars from the large book of knowledge:

 

OK, the three Gulf Cars for the MFH ver B kit are as follows:

 

No. 1    Monza 1000km  Stiffert/Bell              chassis no   917-014/029   car placed  2nd
No. 2    Monza 1000km  Rodriguez/Oliver     chassis no   917-013/043   car placed  1st
No. 19  Le Mans 24hr     Attwood/muller       chassis no   917-026/031   car placed  2nd

 

What’s interesting to note is that the 917 013/043 car is also one of the cars used in the Steve McQueen film of Le mans, the car that David Piper crashed and lost his leg. The car was then completely rebuilt for the 1971 season.

 

I also found out that this particular car survives here in the UK in the National Motor Museum in Beaulieu. I may just have to take a trip up there to photograph it.

 

The Martini No. 22  Le Mans winning car for the Fujimi kit is chassis no. 917/053 and now lives in the Porsche Museum.

 

 

[Borez 714]

OK, so whilst soaking the white metal parts prior to cleaning I decided to do do a few bits on the Fujimi today.

 

First I took the door off, damn fiddly this one was though, up near the hinge there is zero room for error ( and also around the windscreen section. ) It involved using a jewelers saw blade without the frame as I couldn't get the angle with the frame attached, very slow work but finally got it off. The surround just needs sanding and cleaning up

 

I'll be scratch building the tubular frame that goes behind the door and reinforcing the surround with plasticard and tube.

 

Did a little test fit to get a feel of the overall model too

 

 

 

 

Not much going on in the engine bay at all until I get the transkit.

 

 

The rear cowling hinges were not really hinges at all so I've added plasticard and a 0.4mm brass rod to make my own hinge. It's not trimmed in this pic yet.

 

 

So now it has a proper working cowl hinge

 

 

 

 

 

 

Which now closes flush to the bodywork. 

 

 

I also did a test fit of the white metal engine last night and I must admit it was a PITA, the main engine block and gearbox snapped together fine but the cam covers and various other parts just didn't want to fit at all, took ages to re-drill the holes and file the pins to get them to eventually fit flush.

 

I mean, I knew working with white metal would be a different experience and I knew I'd have to remove the flash which was not a difficult job , but I didn't realise it was going to be as tedious and frustrating getting the parts to actually join together. The round and square pins were definitively not fitting in the round and square holes without work here.

 

I'm sure I'll get there though, just a different way of working.

 

Anyway, that's it for now.

 

Thanks for looking in.

 

 

Edited December 23, 2016 by Borez

[Spookytooth 10,032]

Nice start Borez, like the working hinge.

 

Simon.

[injidup 319]

Nice work on the Fujimi car. I plan to make mine pretty much oob but may do another with more detail later. Hope you get your transkit soon.

Also, it's great to hear of your experiences with the multimedia kit, as I'm sure that like me, there are many of us who have never touched one before. Thanks for guiding us through the build.

[Borez 714]

14 minutes ago, injidup said:

Nice work on the Fujimi car. I plan to make mine pretty much oob but may do another with more detail later. Hope you get your transkit soon.

Also, it's great to hear of your experiences with the multimedia kit, as I'm sure that like me, there are many of us who have never touched one before. Thanks for guiding us through the build.

 

I've never built a MFH multimedia kit either, so I'm basically in the same boat too.