Jump to content

'KingForce' Churchill MkIII, El Alamein


Recommended Posts

Hi Guys,

Here is my latest finished model: and AFV Club MkIII Churchill with Inside the Armour interior and a number of scratchbuilt details

When I came to make this one I found out that you can't really build an accurate KingForce churchill out of the box (despite the kits boxtop artwork!) so I have to build a new rear air outlet, a canvass 'dodger for the front, new exhaust pipes, sunshield rails, drop the side air intakes, rearrange the tools and add the stowage seen on so many of these tanks

Anyway, after all that was done, it turned out OK, not perfect, but good enough for its intended use as a demonstrator on the ITA stand at shows :)

Here it is:

IMG_9309.jpg

IMG_9308.jpg

IMG_9307.jpg

IMG_9306.jpg

IMG_9304.jpg

IMG_9303.jpg

IMG_9301.jpg

IMG_9299.jpg

IMG_9298.jpg

IMG_9296.jpg

All comments and constructive criticism is very welcome!

Thanks for looking

Chris

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chris, that's outstanding....!! What a great build... :goodjob:

Cheers,

ggc

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chris - I know a little of armour, but not a lot. But I do know a damn fine model when I see one!! And that is a damn fine model!!

It always amazed me how we got to the Comet and Centurion just a few years after the Churchill ( OK not via the Churchill I know). Theres something about the Churchill that looks like a "what if" Plan 1919 WW1 tank.

Lovely model. One of these days I will build that Comet, and the Alamein Sherman too, unless another Spitfire gets in the way :)

regards

Jonners

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks guys :)

Amazing build Chris. Some of the mods will come in handy for when I do mine. What was the Canvas cover for that is hanging down on the front of the tank?

The canvass is the 'Dodger' The Churchill has a fan called the scirroco fan which, when stood on hard dusty ground, would stir up a huge cloud of dust from underneath the tank. Due to the shape this would concentrate at the front and the back of the tank, as the front the suction from the engine cooling would pull the dust back over the tank blinding the driver and choking everyone else (conjunctivitis was a common complaint with Churchill drivers thanks to the large front facing vision port)

The 'dodger' was designed to block it off. Can't have worked too well though because you only see them on Kingforce Churchills at 2nd Alamein and not in Tunisia, Italy or NWest Europe

Chris

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is a great kit and when I build my next one (mine is finished as Alexsander Nevskii in winter camo) I may well invest in an interior set as well.

However, sorry to bring this up but weren't Kinforce Churchills painted Light Stone over Green? There is an article on the MAFVA website by Mike Starmer which suggests this, and not 'blue-black' over light stone, and I also found a pic which purports to show crews painting the light stone over the standard factory finish green...

Regards

Graeme

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is a great kit and when I build my next one (mine is finished as Alexsander Nevskii in winter camo) I may well invest in an interior set as well.

However, sorry to bring this up but weren't Kinforce Churchills painted Light Stone over Green? There is an article on the MAFVA website by Mike Starmer which suggests this, and not 'blue-black' over light stone, and I also found a pic which purports to show crews painting the light stone over the standard factory finish green...

Regards

Graeme

Thanks Guys :)

Graeme, that's similar to what I thought but then I read this thread on ML

In it there is some good photographic evidence that it was dark over light as the inner parts of the bogeys are light. Unless the crews took the wheels off and were very diligent in painting them light, it is unlikely they started off dark green. In addition, the photos shown there illustrate that in high wear areas the dark has rubbed off leaving the sand colour underneath

Mike Starmer concedes the point in the thread, so I'm guessing this is after his MAFVA article. Mike also says in the thread that veterans describe the colour of the dark camouflage as "'chocolate' 'brick red' and 'earth brown'"

In light of these strong points of reference I chose to paint my churchill based on the IWM photographic evidence and testimony, via Mr Starmer, of veterans

As for your photos, I haven't seen these but I would like to. It could shed some light on the subject. I would say though that later on Churchills of the North Irish Horse in Tunisia are believed to have been delivered in SCC15 The british 'greener' Olive Drab) and camouflaged with light stone. This could be the green and sand scheme? Anyway, I'd like to see those pictures for sure :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NIce build, I am interested in how you interpreted the exhausts as from one photo in particular they look to be angled straight out and not cut flat? Other photos do not seem to show them at all????

Rgds

Neil

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Guys :D

NIce build, I am interested in how you interpreted the exhausts as from one photo in particular they look to be angled straight out and not cut flat? Other photos do not seem to show them at all????

Rgds

Neil

Neil, you are quite right, this is an element of the build that I did not get 100% right. There are three 'incarnations' of the exhausts that I know of:

The kit exhausts are the last incarnation of the exhaust pipe, which stick out of the mufflers at approximately 85%, are quite stort and have a squared plate on the end (which would have been pierced to accept 4 bolts for deep wading extensions

I have gone with the 'initial' type fitted to original MkIs MkIIs and initial production MkIIIs. These curve upward and terminate in a horizontal end parallel to the deck end. These are correct for Dieppe Churchills, and pre-rework scheme (late 1942) churchills.

The thir type is specific to Kinforce churchills only and as you say is the one I should have gone for:

kforceexhausts.jpg

It is highly unlikely they would leave the muffler at a different angle, because that would mean the muffler itself was specific to 12 actual tanks. Very unlikely. Most likely they were a field modification that was not used again. I would think that they leave the muffler at the same 85% angle, then go through a short curve to leave the rest of the pipe at nearer a 70% angle. They are also longer and terminate in a flat cut end to the pipe

If I ever do another Kingforce one, I won't make this mistake again

Chris

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Chris, thought I'd missed something there! Also look at the storage box on the turret they were straight sided not angled!

Did you have plans for the sunshield rails or use the eyeball? I have been putting together all the reference I can find, to finish one off as close as poss to the photos.

Regards

Neil

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...