Jump to content

Mig-21 family Eduard 1/48


harvy5

Recommended Posts

My new project. It will be a building Mig-21 2nd and 3rd generations. Mig-21PF,PFM,R,MA,MF,MFN and US.The basis is a special Eduard "Silver Arrows"

Scan_zpsjkbpfwdi.jpg

and Mig-21MF in Czech and Slovak service.

I started with the worst version of the MiG-21UM Trumpeter is only caricature Mig-21UM. I cut off the fuselage with cockpit and the other is Eduard PFM.It is with that less work as correction of errors at Trumpeter model.

IMG_5704_zpsc0gjppki.jpg

IMG_5705_zps9lwpiojg.jpg

IMG_5706_zpse4i6znqi.jpg

IMG_5707_zps5v15kfnr.jpg

IMG_5713_zpskbgjlimw.jpg

IMG_5714_zpsfua6bl68.jpg

And this is the Mig-21US in NMF with clear varnish..... :banghead:

800px-Czechoslovak_Air_Force_Mikoyan-Gur

image1095961117_zps7z7utabu.jpg

  • Like 8
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Aaaaaargh can't believe you cut up a Eduard Mig-21 😮😉 you're a brave man! Didn't realise the Trumpeter kit was so wrong. Looking forward to seeing this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why is Trumpeter MiG-21UM cartoon? Details chassis, cockpit, engine surface will not comment. :thumbsup: .

The main problem is short fuselage. In the motor section it is 2mm shorter and the front part of the body is 3 mm at the rear. Therefore fuselage looks very strange when compared to the fuselage version of PFM. :banghead:

US and UM version produced reworking front fuselage version of PFM. U version, was based on the PF.

Another problem is the wrong shape control surfaces, flaps and landing gear bays. Evening I will add photos.

Easier for me is the front fuselage Trumpeter UM add to Eduard PFM.It's just Trumpeter model! Only slightly modified form of the model versions F. :hanging:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

fascinating work....

I just got an old Neomega set http://www.modellversium.de/kit/artikel.php?id=529 to convert the Academy MiG-21 PF into a MiG-21 F-13, which Trumpeter have also made, and according to MiG experts, is another classic from Trumpeter, it 'looks' like a F-13.

In my case, i don't know, but given the level of detail gone into on ARC about this I pssed on the Trumpy offering.

I don't have the Academy kit, have been wondering about using the Eduard PF, looks do-able from some eyeballing of the parts.

Any thought on the Trumpeter MiG-21 F-13? Or using the above set?

Lok forward to updates.

cheers

T

Link to comment
Share on other sites

fascinating work....

I just got an old Neomega set http://www.modellversium.de/kit/artikel.php?id=529 to convert the Academy MiG-21 PF into a MiG-21 F-13, which Trumpeter have also made, and according to MiG experts, is another classic from Trumpeter, it 'looks' like a F-13.

In my case, i don't know, but given the level of detail gone into on ARC about this I pssed on the Trumpy offering.

I don't have the Academy kit, have been wondering about using the Eduard PF, looks do-able from some eyeballing of the parts.

Any thought on the Trumpeter MiG-21 F-13? Or using the above set?

Lok forward to updates.

cheers

T

Exactly this step I want to do! Eduard PF model and conversion Neomega.Problem but is.... Neomega is for model Academi has a bad diameter of the fuselage.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Exactly this step I want to do! Eduard PF model and conversion Neomega.Problem but is.... Neomega is for model Academi has a bad diameter of the fuselage.

Kits not to hand, but I will try to use calipers and contour gauge to see how much difference.

The Neomega set does replace all the front fuselage though. When I was comparing the Neomega with Eduard I couldn't a major difference in size, but that was by eye.

Looking here http://sternlaurent.free.fr/migModeling/48kitsComparaison/academyVsEduardVsOez.html

i did notice that Neomega have thicker wing leading edges to match the Academy.

Thus discusses Eduard vs Academy.

http://www.arcforums.com/forums/air/index.php?showtopic=227656

EDIT looking at the post linked in the ARC thread, I found this image

image.jpg

Dark grey is Eduard, note that the Neomega set replaces bulged up spine on the Academy, and use the rear fuselage which looks to be the same diameter

529-5009.jpg

hope of interest, if not to you, to other readers.

cheers

T

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very interesting Troy. I have discussed with one fellow modeller about Mig 21F-13 and -Bis. He is former mechanic and knows these quite well and he's opinion is that making good one requires using several kits. And looking your mail seems to confirm this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not saying that Eduard is perfect, but at the moment it is the best model Mig-21. I'm a former mechanic Su-25, but at the airport we had a Mig-21 and also in schools. So something about him also know.

And now a few differences between the Trumpeter and Eduard ....

IMG_5735_zpshp94nizv.jpg

IMG_5733_zpsy3a7dw5l.jpg

IMG_5730_zpsf73jrx8l.jpg

IMG_5729_zpsooss8gdc.jpg

... probably the biggest problem Trumpeter. I think that only modified the rudder of the MiG-21F.

IMG_5721_zpsg8fr0kvj.jpg

IMG_5734_zps6zpwe1as.jpg

Trumpeter rudder to Eduard model

IMG_5728_zpsnysrzohl.jpg

IMG_5727_zpsybnqz8dd.jpg

... and now little progress in other versions,from the top PF,PFM and R/MF

IMG_5720_zpsfpdfnrzi.jpg

IMG_5719_zpsr7vl80wg.jpg

IMG_5718_zpso0drentj.jpg

cockpit PF

IMG_5737_zpsdryc9sid.jpg

IMG_5740_zps3iugwubf.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very interesting Troy. I have discussed with one fellow modeller about Mig 21F-13 and -Bis. He is former mechanic and knows these quite well and he's opinion is that making good one requires using several kits. And looking your mail seems to confirm this.

I'm late to the party on the MiG-21, for anyone browsing this who is confused by the the F-13/PF/PFM/FL/MF/R etc etc this page

http://www.mig-21.de/english/technicaldataversions.htm

is the simplest basic guide!

For those browsing, and curious,

In short Eduard have kitted most of the 2nd, 3rd and 4th generation variants, see above link, with the notable exception of the FL.

They have also not as yet done the 1st generation, the F/F-13, though possibly they won't, which is a real shame as these were widely used. Trumpeter have done the F-13, which seems to be a typical Trumpeter kit, 'looks' like the subject but not if you know the subject.

Hence my interest in the Neomega F-13, which looks very good in the box, and comes with Equipage wheels as well.

My interest comes from Arab use, (damn Tom Cooper and those Arab MiG books...) and Indian use, which is annoying as these use a lot of F-13's and FL's.....

Tom also does the ACIG site, some examples

Indian use

http://www.acig.info/CMS/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=168&Itemid=47

http://www.acig.info/CMS/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=169&Itemid=47

Thread here on the FL

http://www.britmodeller.com/forums/index.php?/topic/234981982-mig-21-question-indian-air-force/

Arab Airforces June 1967

http://www.acig.info/CMS/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=176&Itemid=47

Hope of interest

Regarding the MiG-21bis, seems Eduard tried to use the same nose as the 2nd/3rd Gen kits, and it's different, though there is a resin replacement.

http://www.britmodeller.com/forums/index.php?/topic/234979859-cold-war-studio-resin-and-pe-for-eduard-mig-21bis-trumpeter-mig-15-and-revell-mig-29/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Again little progress. Already are similar to the MiG-21 2nd generation.

PF cockpit is PE and PFM from decal.From production had PF and PF cockpits in gray, and after overhaul changed to turquoise.

IMG_5750_zpsuesellb9.jpg

IMG_5751_zpssfxmxfre.jpg

IMG_5760_zpscicpxt1n.jpg

IMG_5756_zpsyvvh3bso.jpg... and one common photo MiG-21PF, PFM and the US

IMG_5755_zpsmtl0ykxy.jpg

And this is the first Mig to this family. Mig-21MF

IMG_5257_zps4f14b4c3.jpg

IMG_5254_zps51206637.jpg

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

After a long time little progress. Now comes what I do not like stencils ...

IMG_5852_zpsvoow1z4d.jpg

IMG_5850_zps76ydd9kq.jpg

IMG_5847_zpstxmpbo2x.jpgIMG_5849_zpsdqbcha2x.jpg

Edited by harvy5
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 5 weeks later...
  • 1 year later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...