Jump to content

A windy day at Birmingham International


bootneck

Recommended Posts

All well flown holding the centreline reasonably well given the conditions, 1st Flybe Q400 might need a heavy landing check and a bit if a brown trousers moment as the steering was transferred from tiller to rudder at 10:09, could be the same Q400

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for posting that. I remember now why I never bid for a BHX base during my flying career. In common with LBA, a N-S runway isn't ideal when the wind prevails from the SW. Still had to go there a few scary times though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great Vid, I'm amazed that they have a construction site in the undershoot/overshoot area and are still operating :yikes:

If you stand at any base/airport near this area they ask you to move on for your own safety, but here is an area full of diggers and cabin/containers!

Shaun.

Edited by Shaun
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is it me or is the runway extremely short and very 'lumpy'?

Mark

It's the foreshortening effect of the telephoto lens used for the filming, when viewed normally the place has humps but not as bad as the video suggests.

Shaun.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My flightsim mates say my landings are always like that :rolleyes: ,the rotters.

Blimey,some ring-twitching,rudder pedalling,tyre scrubbing brown trooser moments there I'll say.

Well done to all pilots for getting 'em in/out safely in those conditions.

Brum has got a hilly runway hasn't it :o

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chris, Thought that one looked like it might need a heavy landing check. Was it as heavy as it looked?

Mark

Mark,

I don't actually know who did that one but it was almost certainly heavy. We were the Dash 8 that went around afterwards in the video and got in on the second attempt. It looks to all intents and purposes that the one in question caught the downdraft off the Monarch hangar and dropped, which would explain the lack of crosswind technique. It seems to occur in the last 30 feet and is really worth carrying extra speed for - even armed with this fact, we lost about 20 knots in this time period leading up to us going around.

I reckon the first one almost certainly was a heavy landing. At some stages, there were 4 of our aircraft out with them across the network for such reasons!!

Chris

Edited by Chris Jephcott
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What was the wind doing that day Chris? At least it was dry! I don't think any of us have seen weather like this winter in our flying careers, especially the sustained strong winds. It wasn't just the wind on the ground that was the problem. Most approaches you were flying with 60 to 70 kts of wind until very late in the approach with associated turbulence and windshear. I went round 3 times and diverted twice in 6 weeks, more than my total for the last 15 years! There were a few 'sweaty palm' moments!!

Cheers

Glen

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It still amazes me you manage to get these things down in calm conditions!

The nearest parallel in my experience is my narrowboat; even a moderate cross wind will have me going at an angle along the cut; one of the effects of not having a keel. Even at 4mph it can make life interesting............

Chris

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is great! I usually fly from Birmingham on holiday, and I think it would be funny if they showed this as the inflight movie!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Glen,

I think the wind according the TAF only occassionally ventured above 55kts for Birmingham throughout the entire winter. However, there is rumoured to be a hearty difference between the wind given by tower and the actual wind - in fact, to this day, where they get their readings from is a total mystery.

If I recall correctly, I think it was gusting up to 45kts on that day. However, with the new Monarch hangar at the side of the runway, there are a whole series of totally different wind effects in the last 100 feet... Adding that to the conditions this winter, it's not really a surprise how many people have ended up diverting away from Birmingham over the last few months - which isn't great if you consider that 15/33 has bizarrely been not too far being into wind during the strong days!!

It's been a bad winter for diverts and go arounds. I can't remember any prolonged time period quite like this before - and summer is hopefully going to provide a much welcomed break. At least it wasn't snow and endless waiting around for the de-icing truck this year!

Chris

Link to comment
Share on other sites

However, there is rumoured to be a hearty difference between the wind given by tower and the actual wind - in fact, to this day, where they get their readings from is a total mystery.

I'm sure some places have the anemometer indoors! I've often wondered when I'm told 10kts whilst looking at a horizontal windsock.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...