Jump to content


Photo

Airfix Spitfire IX "Club Special" Israel and Egypt


  • Please log in to reply
38 replies to this topic

#1 John

John

    Very Obsessed Member

  • Gold Member
  • 2,812 posts

Posted 01 July 2013 - 09:16 AM

Well, a bit after WWII actually. I was ordering one or two bits and pieces from the Airfix website last week and decided to treat myself to the limited edition 1/48th scale Spitfire IX kit. It's the same plastic as the multi-version MkIX/MkXVI that first came out a few years ago with a specially produced dcal sheet for an Egyptian and an Israeli aircraft.

 

The kit comes in the standard Club Special "pizza box", a bit bigger than A4 in size and featrures a couple of nice profiles on the lid:

 

boxtop_zpsfbdf7ed7.jpg

 

The decal sheet is by Cartograf and is beautifully printed. It contains all the major markings and blocks of colour in case any patching is needed. there are no stencils though:

 

decals_zpscbf1f46b.jpg

 

The first option is for an Royal Egyptian Air Force McIXc numbered 664 and dated September 1948:

 

Egypt_zpsbf19ef51.jpg

 

Colours are standard RAF wartime desert scheme but the pattern as shown doesn't appear to be the one normally associated with the Spitfire - local repaint perhaps? The decal sheet also provided the letter "L" in red for the starboard side only.

 

The second option is an Israeli MkIXe No 2004/14, 101 Squadron, 1949. This has clipped wings and looks to be in pretty much standard Day Fighter Scheme colours and pattern:

 

Israel_zps7029d70e.jpg

 

The kit instructions are slightly modified from the standard release of the kit in that, understandably, they don't mention some of the optional parts for the MkXVI. However they do suggest that both options should have the "e" wing armament layout, which I would imagine is wrong for the Egyptian aircraft. The painting instructions also show an "e" wing on both options.

 

All in all, it's a nice package and probably worth a substantial part of the purchase price just for the decal sheet. I know the kit has been criticised in the past, rightly, for the heavy trailing edges and overall "softness", but I've always found that it builds up nicely with a bit of work. I do wish Airfix would take a lead from Eduard's book and abandon the fixation with lowered flaps on their Spitfires - I strongly suspect that this is what gives rise to the problems with the wing trailing edges.

 

I have a load of Aeroclub and Brengun updates for this kit, plus plenty of ICM spares, so sorting out the bits that need fixed won't be an issue. I'm putting the plastic aside to build as a MkVIII with the Aeroclub retractable tailwheel set. I'll use one of the decal options on an Eduard "c" or "e", but I haven't decided which one yet. I like the Egyptian option though...

 

John

 

 

 



#2 NPL

NPL

    Obsessed Member

  • Members
  • 526 posts

Posted 01 July 2013 - 12:50 PM

Nice idea. I have both planes covered in 1/48, the "14" via

 

Sky’s Decals SD-21 (18 Israeli Spitfires in all--although maybe not "14"). The Egyptian plane is also found on a Techmod sheet +

ADS 010-48 Middle Eastern Spitfires 1948, part 1 (an old sheet) that also includes the IAF "14". The peculiar thing about this Egyptian plane has to do with the identification strips which according to ADS would make the D-Day stripes look neat also on gliders.

 

NPL



#3 John

John

    Very Obsessed Member

  • Gold Member
  • 2,812 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 10:28 AM

You can also do the same aircraft in 1/72 scale with this sheet from Lift Here Decals:

 

http://lifthereserbi...rk-nine-in-172/

 

The Spitfire rigged with the Luftwaffe-style drop tank is interesting!

 

John



#4 Nigel Heath

Nigel Heath

    Attitude Adjuster

  • Gold Member
  • 4,717 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 11:56 AM

Both are attractive schemes, which one are you going for? I marginally prefer the Egyptian one, I think.

#5 John

John

    Very Obsessed Member

  • Gold Member
  • 2,812 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 12:20 PM

I like the Egyptian one as well, if I can get the camouflage pattern straight in my head.  I find myself wondering about the armament though, as this photo of a crashed Egyptian Spitfire is pretty clearly an "e":

 

http://img.photobuck...liya-01-003.jpg

 

John



#6 Jennings Heilig

Jennings Heilig

    Very Obsessed Member

  • Members
  • 4,643 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 12:40 PM

The REAF bird is most definitely an IXc.  Also, the "14" is about 20% too large, and the style of numbers for the "2004" is incorrect (they were hand painted).



#7 John

John

    Very Obsessed Member

  • Gold Member
  • 2,812 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 01:23 PM

The REAF bird is most definitely an IXc.  <snip>

The aircraft in the photo doesn't seem to have the outboard .303 gun bays a "c" would have. It looks a lot like an "e" wing to me.

 

John

 

Edited to add : 

 

Another photo of the same wreck - no outboard mg muzzles visible:

 

http://www.survivalw...07/NA005567.jpg

 

J



#8 Black Knight

Black Knight

    slightly eccentric

  • Gold Member
  • 899 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 01:56 PM

I have a different photo of a shot down REAF Mk9, it shows a 'c' wing.

Going by photos of Weismann's IDF/AF 17 the 14 is too big.

 

F



#9 John

John

    Very Obsessed Member

  • Gold Member
  • 2,812 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 02:33 PM

Interesting stuff, thanks. This one's a "c" by the look of it:

 

http://upload.wikime..._Abu_Agaila.jpg

 

John



#10 NPL

NPL

    Obsessed Member

  • Members
  • 526 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 03:58 PM

I can recommend  two books by Alex Yofe, Spitfire: Star of Israel (Ventura 1996), and Spitfire Mk.IX in the Israeli Air Force (White Crow Publ.  2006). Plenty of Photos, also of the two selected by Airfix.  Here you also find several shots of the German style drop tanks. These drop tanks go back to the Velveta 1 and 2, the transfer of Czech Spitfires via Yugoslavia.

 

White 14, IAF, definitely an E. The "14" is oversized (not much), as if Airfix used the profile in Stars of Israel (p. 21) instead of the Photos on the previous page. I am not so sure that they were handpainted. They look fairly regular to me. Maybe they used masks. According to Yofe (Star of Israel p. 20)there were no identification strips on the upper wing at "14"

 

Red L's roundel (at least right side) had a strange tilt, not found in Airfix's profile (Spitfire Mk.IX, p. 49).

 

NPL

 

If possible always work on the basis of photographical material.



#11 John

John

    Very Obsessed Member

  • Gold Member
  • 2,812 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 04:14 PM

Thanks for the pointers, it isn't really an area I'm that familiar with. I think I might use Eduard's late "c" and build the Egyptian version.

 

John



#12 NPL

NPL

    Obsessed Member

  • Members
  • 526 posts

Posted 02 July 2013 - 05:21 PM

Thanks for the pointers, it isn't really an area I'm that familiar with. I think I might use Eduard's late "c" and build the Egyptian version.

 

John

 

Yofe has the red L as an E. But it is a mess as the Israelis laid hand on several Egyptian Spitfires. However, a definite Egyptian C would be a Mk.Vc.

 

NPL



#13 NPL

NPL

    Obsessed Member

  • Members
  • 526 posts

Posted 03 July 2013 - 06:08 AM

Addendum: On White 14, the Magen David roundels on the side were lined in blue. The people behind the Club version should have done a better homework.

 

NPL



#14 AlCZ

AlCZ

    Established Member

  • Members
  • 240 posts

Posted 03 July 2013 - 02:48 PM

Nice decals option. But - Eduard's Mk IXc and IXe are better choice, no ?



#15 Jennings Heilig

Jennings Heilig

    Very Obsessed Member

  • Members
  • 4,643 posts

Posted 03 July 2013 - 08:59 PM

Addendum: On White 14, the Magen David roundels on the side were lined in blue. The people behind the Club version should have done a better homework.

 

 

If you read the history, it's probable that the blue "outline" is nothing more than the remains of a slightly larger Yugoslav roundel that the aircraft carried on the trip from Yugoslavia to Israel.  The white of the IDF roundel was (for some reason) painted smaller than the Yugoslav.

 

Also, note that there is no evidence that the Luftwaffe 300l drop tanks were ever used in combat.  Only for the long trip from Europe to Israel.

 

 

Spit2004.jpg


Edited by Jennings Heilig, 03 July 2013 - 09:02 PM.

  • Moggy likes this

#16 NPL

NPL

    Obsessed Member

  • Members
  • 526 posts

Posted 04 July 2013 - 04:38 AM

 

If you read the history, it's probable that the blue "outline" is nothing more than the remains of a slightly larger Yugoslav roundel that the aircraft carried on the trip from Yugoslavia to Israel.  The white of the IDF roundel was (for some reason) painted smaller than the Yugoslav.

 

Also, note that there is no evidence that the Luftwaffe 300l drop tanks were ever used in combat.  Only for the long trip from Europe to Israel.

 

 

Spit2004.jpg

 

It might all be right, but you see the dark line very clearly. Then this blue board is also very regular as on the profile included in your mail. The profile of 14 in Star of Israel has the board in the same colour as the Magen David, but looking a second time at the Photos in Yofe's two volumes, the profile may indicate that you are right, making also your theory about an overpainted Yugoslav roundel likely.

 

The German fuel tanks have nothing to do with White 14 as she appears here, and it would be strange to believe that they were carried into fight, when you think of the small operational area we are talking about. This is also confirmed by Yofe saying that there is no evidence of them being used for training and in operations. Although in Stars of Israel p. 38, ill. 70, you have a detailed Photo of an Israeli seemingly rather worn battleship at Hatzor in 1949. As the Velveta 2 (the transfer from Czekoslovakia) took place in December 1948, it might be that it had not been removed yet, although nothing is said about the Photo except 1949, in Israel. The other Pictures of Spitfires in transfer had these tanks plus the normal slipper tank on Spitfires.

 

A final note, the white blue identification strips under the wings were only found on a couple of early planes in Israel, and finally, 14 was SOC in January 1949 after an incident. It was one of those who made it during the Velveta 1 in September 1948.

 

NPL



#17 Work In Progress

Work In Progress

    Very Obsessed Member

  • Members
  • 2,652 posts

Posted 04 July 2013 - 07:58 AM

Nice decals option. But - Eduard's Mk IXc and IXe are better choice, no ?

 

The Eduard plastic is better, and so is that of the ICM kits. But then they haven't released kits with these decals.



#18 AlCZ

AlCZ

    Established Member

  • Members
  • 240 posts

Posted 04 July 2013 - 02:21 PM

In last month Eduard's super limited edition "Naši se vracejí" (Our boys are back...) were most markings for IAF Spifires... In Royal Class is one Israeli Spit too... Yes, Egyptian decals are not included - but i'm sure  decals producers made Mid east war decals soon :) And Airfix "nine" is really tragic kit :( 



#19 NPL

NPL

    Obsessed Member

  • Members
  • 526 posts

Posted 04 July 2013 - 03:29 PM

I made a survey of what I have in my collection of decals from the Middle East, Israel and Egypt

I hope that it is of some help, although I am quite aware of the fact that several of these are not easily available any more.

 

 

Eduard Royal Edition

     LF Mk.IXe, SL632, 26, IAF, late 1949

 

ADS 010 48 Middle Eastern Spitfires 1948, part 1

     Mk.IXc, D-130, 101 Sqdn, IAF

     MK.IXc,’Black 10’, 2001, IAF; LFIXe,’White 14’/2004, IAF

     Mk.IXc, Red’L’, 664, 2 Sqdn, REAF

 

Kagero Topcolor No. 15 Special Edition Spitfire Mk. IX

     LF Mk.IXc, ‘26’, IAF, mid 1949

     LF Mk.IXc, ‘14’ IAF Jan 1949

 

Techmod Decals 48064ASupermarine Spitfire Mk.IX

     Mk.IX, White 26, 101 Sqdn, IAF

     Mk.IX, Black 10, 101 Sqdn, IAF

     Mk.IX, L’ of REAF.

 

Skyʼs Decals SD-21 IAF First Fighters

    Mk.IX, 2058, The ‘silver Spitfire’, 1952

    Mk.IXe, 2057, the ‘Black Spitfire’ [Ezar Weisman]

    D-130 Israel 1, Ma’abarot Airfield July/August 1948

    2001, 101 Sqn, June/July 1949, sort 10

    2002, 101 Sqn, Mid 1949

    Mk.XIe, 2003, 101 Sqn, December 1948, hvid 12

    Mk.IXe, 2004, 191 Sqn, January 1949

    Mk.IXe, 2013, 101 Sqn

    Mk.IXe, 2010, 101 Sqn, hvid 25

    Mk.IXe, 2011, 101 Sqn, hvid 26

    Mk.IXe, 2018, 101 Sqn, hvid 17

    Mk.IXe, 2012, 101 Sqn, hvid 16

    Mk.IXe, 2023, 101 Sqn, late 1948, hvid 31

    Mk.IXe, 105 Sqn, 1950, hvid 33

    Mk.IXe, 2011, 105 Sqn, sort 26

    Mk.IXe, 2063, 105 Sqn, Mid 1955, sort 63

    Mk.IXe, 89, Sqn 105, 1955

    Mk. IXc, 2080, 107 Sqn, late 1953, sort 80

 

Ventura V4858 Israeli Spitfire Mk.IXʼs

    Mk.IXe, 2011/26, IAF

    Mk.IXe, 64, IAF 

    Mk.IXe, 48, IAF

 

Ventura V4874 Israeli Spitfires. Pt. II

    Mk.IXe, 69, IAF

    Mk.IXe, 79, 107 Sqdn, IAF

 

Ventura V4822 Spitfires—Australian, New Zealand and Israeli

    Mk.IX, D-130,’Israel 1’, IAF

 

Watermark Decals 48006 Canadian Spitfires: Assorted Markings

    Mk.IXe, 2008, 15, 101 Sqdn, IAF [Denny Wilson]

 

 

Egyptian alone:

 

AeroMaster Decals 48-042 Spitfire Mk. V Collection

     Mk.Vc, JK195/C, REAF

 

Decals Carpena 48.87 Spitfire Exotics Part. 6

    Mk.Vc, JK195, C, 107 M.U., REAF

 

Eagle Strike Productions 48211 End of the Line Mk.22/24 Pt. II

    F 22, 681, 2 Sqdn, REAF, Helwan 1950

 

Eduard's upcoming special edition seems to have three IAF Spitfires, white 57 in two deliveries and white 26 (the one with the eagle and the Spitfire).

 

NPL


Edited by NPL, 04 July 2013 - 03:33 PM.


#20 Roo

Roo

    New Member

  • Members
  • 96 posts

Posted 04 July 2013 - 04:19 PM

In last month Eduard's super limited edition "Naši se vracejí" (Our boys are back...) were most markings for IAF Spifires... In Royal Class is one Israeli Spit too... Yes, Egyptian decals are not included - but i'm sure  decals producers made Mid east war decals soon :) And Airfix "nine" is really tragic kit :(

Yup, and it forms the basis of all the main 1:48 spits. I have built 2 Airfix IX's for both of these decal options and 2 XVIe's with a Mk1 in the stash, and they all have the same plastic and they are not very nice to build. Also they do not come with a genuine wheels up option so you have to use the kit parts and filler to make it so.